‹ Figure Out Science Physics · Gravity

Newton’s cannonball: why the Moon doesn’t fall

Put a cannon on a very tall mountain and fire ever harder. The ball lands farther and farther away — until it falls in a way that never hits the ground. You have just invented the orbit.

This thought experiment is over three hundred years old and is still the shortest route to understanding spaceflight. Newton sketched it in his "Treatise of the System of the World": a cannon on a mountain so tall it reaches above the atmosphere. Fire — the ball falls beyond the horizon. Fire harder — it falls farther. And at a certain speed, something strange happens. Try it yourself: move the slider and fire.

One cannon, three fates: fall, orbit, escape
Muzzle speed
6,0 km/s
7.91 km/s = circular orbit
Status
fate of the last shot
Orbits
0
full trips around Earth
Apogee
highest point of the orbit
Muzzle speed6,0 km/s

Model: Earth without an atmosphere (Newton’s mountain sits above it), horizontal shot. Time scale sped up.

Fig. 1 — Raise the speed and fire · from a fall, to an orbit, to escape

A fall that keeps missing

A cannonball always falls — gravity makes no exceptions. But the Earth is round, so its surface drops away beneath the flight path: over every 8 kilometres of horizontal distance, the ground "falls" by about 5 metres. Now for the key coincidence: a freely falling body drops about 5 metres in its first second. So if the ball flies horizontally at 8 kilometres per second, it falls by exactly as much as the ground curves away. It keeps falling — and it keeps missing.

The key formula
v = √(GM/r)
circular orbit speed · at the Earth’s surface 7.9 km/s · escape speed is √2 times larger ≈ 11.2 km/s

The Moon has been falling for 4.5 billion years

The Moon does exactly the same. Every second it falls towards the Earth by a fraction of a millimetre — precisely enough to bend its straight path into a circle. Newton computed that fraction, compared it with a falling apple, and the numbers agreed: the same force governs the orchard and the heavens. That was the moment terrestrial and celestial physics became one science.

An orbit is a fall that forever misses the ground.

From cannon to rocket

This picture corrects the most common misconception about rockets: getting to orbit is not a problem of altitude but of speed. You could, in principle, take an elevator a hundred kilometres up — and you would fall straight back down. Rockets launch vertically only to get out of the thick atmosphere, then pitch over and accelerate along the horizon to those ~7.8 km/s. Almost all the fuel is spent on horizontal speed, not on height.

In the figure you will also find a third regime: above 11.2 km/s the ball’s energy is positive and no ellipse will ever bring it back — that is escape velocity, a one-way ticket out of Earth’s gravity. Between the circular orbit and escape stretches a whole family of ellipses — the very paths flown by the GPS satellites of our next article.

A simplificationWe ignore air resistance (Newton’s mountain deliberately reaches above the atmosphere — near the surface the ball would burn up in seconds), treat the Earth as a uniform sphere, and fire perfectly horizontally. The mountain’s height in the figure is exaggerated for clarity. The core stays exact: the entire flight path follows from one law — Newtonian gravity.

Bibliography (sample)

  1. 1 Newton, I. — "A Treatise of the System of the World" (1728) — where the cannon drawing appears. archive.org
  2. 2 Feynman, R. P. — "The Feynman Lectures on Physics", Vol. I, lecture 7 "The Theory of Gravitation". caltech.edu
  3. 3 Bate, R., Mueller, D. & White, J. — "Fundamentals of Astrodynamics", Dover (1971). ISBN 978-0486600611
  4. 4 OpenStax — "University Physics, Vol. 1: Gravitation" (open access). openstax.org
Always ad-free

This article is free — and will stay that way

No ads, no paywall. If it helped you understand the topic, support the making of the next one.

Support the magazine Join the newsletter
Keep reading
All topics →
Navigation How GPS works 8 min read · Read →
Optics · The atmosphere The rainbow: an arc written in every raindrop 7 min read · Read →
Optics · The atmosphere Why the sky is blue (and sunsets are red) 7 min read · Read →
Optics Converging lenses: how an image forms 12 min read · Read →